The text below is taken from the book "Bologna nella seconda guerra mondiale" (chapter dedicated to "Bologna e gli ebrei") written by C. Federici, private edition 1993. The book is a collection of research and accounts by the author.
(…) The events related to Nazi policy against the Jews, even if only partially and poorly known in Italy, were more than enough to arouse dismay and concern: it is true that up to that moment Italian Jews had no tangible reason to fear the future, but everyone knew and realised how the alliance between Italy and Germany, or rather between Mussolini and Hitler, was becoming ever closer, and the political ideals of the two regimes, fascism and nazism, were increasingly identifying with one another. It was therefore not absurd to think that Mussolini might also be infected by Hitler's fanatical and uncontrollable anti-Jewish hatred. And indeed, between 1936 and 1937 one began to notice that in our country “something” was changing, even though the fascist government continued to declare that Jews were absolutely equal to other Italian citizens.
Following Mussolini's visit to Berlin in September 1937, after a few months and precisely at the beginning of 1938, came the opening of the anti-Jewish journalistic campaign: in Bologna, the "Resto del Carlino" opened hostilities almost in a muted tone against "foreign students" attending our university, denouncing that the city would soon be invaded by all the Jewish students expelled from Romania. Secondly, in another article, also in the Carlino, signed by "Black Shirt", the pseudonym of Piero Pedrazza, Editor-in-Chief of the newspaper, it was proposed to "close the doors of the University to all foreign Jews". It was the first overt "gust of wind" preceding an imminent and dangerous worsening of the weather.
After other articles concerning "foreign" students and graduates, an obvious pretext to give the "go-ahead" for quite a different discourse, increasingly openly threatening blurbs followed.
On 20 May 1938 the Ministry of Popular Culture (Minculpop) ordered that "German Israeli authors' books must not be reviewed"; this was the first official provision of the fascist government against Jews, for now only "German", issued, as it happened, right after Hitler's visit to Rome on 3 May!
On 14 July, on behalf of Minculpop, about ten scientists (including Arturo Donaggio, Director of the Neurological Clinic of the University of Bologna) published a manifesto entitled "Italian Racism": the Resto del Carlino, in its commentary, wrote that this manifesto had a basis "not only biological but above all spiritual", and was aimed only at defending the Italian race, and not against the Jews... Truly a poor attempt to make people believe that Italian racism was "different" from the German one! And the first not to believe it was the Pope, Pius XI, who, on 28 July, publicly raised the suspicion that "Italian racism was an imitative phenomenon", stating that in the world there exists "only one human race".
On 30 July, commenting on the above, the Bolognese newspaper "L'Avvenire d'Italia" came out with an article entitled "The Pope against the excesses of racism and nationalism".
"Fascist" Italy, now completely subservient to Hitlerian Nazism, had taken a path unfortunately with no return, and government measures against the Jews followed one another with shameful frequency.
On 21 July the government prohibited Jews from going abroad; in August it forbade foreign Jews from enrolling in Italian universities.
The Resto del Carlino, which in the antisemitic racial campaign is truly "commendable", also lashed out against mixed marriages and, while not going so far as to propose the annulment of those already celebrated, hoped for a law prohibiting them in the future.
In the month of September the government stipulated that "Jewish teachers and pupils be excluded from schools" from 16 October.
In the month of October all tenured professors, tenured and voluntary assistants, and freelance lecturers of the Jewish race were expelled from our University.
The Jewish tenured professors were eleven: Tullio Ascarelli, Alberto Mario Camis, Gustavo del Vecchio, Emanuele Foà, Guido Horn d'Arturo, Beppo Levi, Rodolfo Mandolfo, Maurizio Pincherle, Beniamino Segre, Giulio Supino, Edoardo Volterra.
The expulsion of Jewish lecturers from our University—which, due to the ancient fame of its glorious past and the current renown of its professors, was ranked among the foremost in the world—had profound and painful repercussions on all citizens, and especially on those who completed their studies at the Bolognese Alma Mater, many of them under the guidance of those very teachers who were ignominiously driven out. Never had the centuries-old history of the oldest university in the world had to suffer such shame. The racism of the Bolognese The claim by Saverio Pòlito, Police Commissioner of Bologna in those years, that “the people support the Fascist racial policy with all their might” is absolutely false and in bad faith. The vast majority of the Bolognese, by nature, has never been racist, let alone antisemitic. For example, during the years of the anti-Jewish Fascist persecution, only three premises in Bologna displayed the sign banning access to Jews, and very few were the antisemitic writings on the walls of houses. The Bolognese Catholic Church too, more or less energetically, always took a stand against the racist policy of Fascism; suffice it to recall the two homilies delivered by Cardinal G. B. Nasalli Rocca, Archbishop of Bologna, on Christmas Day in 1938 and on the day of the Epiphany in 1939. In the first homily, the Bishop stated that “men are all one family of Jesus Christ, who is the firstborn thereof … Away then with certain exotic and ill-considered ideologies inspired by an exaggerated nationalism, which end up digging unbridgeable chasms … by failing to recognise the natural bond of common origin from a single primitive couple … “ And on the day of the Epiphany, after reiterating the concepts of paganism “which today they wish to make be reborn”, he added: “How much ignorance in many! To the point of failing to understand this fundamental truth of Christianity, the unity and brotherhood of all men in Jesus Christ!” Even though out of 413 parishes then included in the Diocese of Bologna, only about ten parish priests openly and courageously expressed their anti-racist feelings, it cannot be said that the Bolognese Church ever adhered to, or even sympathised with, the antisemitic policy of Fascism. Unfortunately, even though they were few, supporters of antisemitism were not lacking in Bologna, especially among the intellectual class. Let us remember Prof. Donaggio, a signatory among other things of the “Manifesto of Race”; Prof. Frassetto, defined as “one of the great precursors of Italian racism”; Prof. Alessandro Chigi, Rector of the University, a rabid racist; Prof. Ezio Chiorboli, Headmaster of the Liceo Ginnasio Galvani; and the entire editorial staff of “Il Resto del Carlino”, with the Director and Editor-in-Chief at the head, which played such a huge part in the fierce, violent and sometimes even unfair campaign against the Jews. When on 10 June 1940 Italy entered the war, the situation of foreign Jews worsened: they were all arrested and interned. But dangers increased for Italian Jews as well, dangers that sometimes not even the Jews themselves knew about. For example, nobody knew that, by explicit order of Mussolini, a concentration camp was being prepared for them! And with the war, further provisions against them were issued: seizure of radio sets, prohibition of publishing obituaries in newspapers, exclusion from all cinematic, theatrical and musical shows … In May 1942, conscription for forced labour was also decreed for all Jews, male and female, from 18 to 55 years of age. In Bologna, the Jews were almost all exempted “for health reasons” thanks to the Provincial Medical Officer Francesco Addari, who “did his utmost to declare a very small number of Jews as fit for work” (from a Report of the Jewish Community of Bologna dated 12/3/1948). Always in the aforementioned Jewish Report one reads: “From 1938 to 1943 the laws were applied ‘pro forma’ and indeed the Authorities tried in every way not to make us feel their weight”, in particular due to the work carried out by the then Secretary to the Police Commissioner Dr Umberto Muoio. Another proof of Bolognese anti-racism. The situation of the Jews plunged towards tragedy after 8 September 1943, when the government of Vittorio Emanuele signed the armistice with the Allies, and the whole of central-northern Italy was occupied by the Germans. Who could possibly prevent the Nazi law against Jews from being applied in our country as well? Soon everything was ready to deport our Jews: the first round-up took place in Rome on 16 October, then it was Milan's turn. But due to the incompetence of the German officer in charge of coordinating operations, and because of the hesitations and oppositions of the RSI government, there were no further round-ups. In November 1943 Mussolini's government resolved that “those belonging to the Jewish race are foreigners. During this war they belong to enemy nationalities”. Ultimately, this very harsh resolution could prove advantageous for Jews who, as prisoners of enemy nationality, ought to be kept in Italian concentration camps until the end of the war. But on the other hand, the Germans, practically “masters” of our country, could much more easily pick them up and send them to their camps … In Bologna, faced with this state of affairs, the Jews did not remain idle: many of them, who had long since rented houses or premises in out-of-the-way places far from inhabited centres, hastened to leave Bologna. Others instead, while staying in the city, were able to hide with Aryan citizens. And this was possible because the vast majority of the Bolognese were anti-racist and sympathised with them; risking terrible punishments if discovered, they not only hid them by giving them shelter, but maintained them if necessary until the end of the war. Thus, when on 7 November the Germans, with the collaboration of the Fascists, triggered the first raid, the Jews had already almost all disappeared from the addresses indicated in the lists provided by Police Headquarters. The few who were captured – seventeen it seems – were almost immediately loaded onto a train coming from Rome, already full of Jews, and directed to Auschwitz. The “hunt for Jews” naturally continued: but of the 864 Jews who were in Bologna on 8 September, only about 10% fell victim to the Nazis; and this thanks to the help of the entire population: clinics, hospitals, parishes, religious institutions and private homes welcomed the Jews and protected them as best they could. Some Jews, instead of hiding, preferred to join the partisan struggle and fight for common freedom. According to some calculations, the Bolognese Jews who died in the camps numbered 114; only 36 of them, before being sent to the extermination camps, passed through the San Giovanni in Monte Prison. When the war finally ended with the defeat of Nazism, for millions of people the nightmare that had oppressed them for a full six years came to an end; and certainly, those who rejoiced more than anyone else were the Jews, for whom life and hope in the future were being reborn. Hope, but not certainty, because racist hatred is a sentiment that has always existed and which, alas, will perhaps always exist.
Following the university category, that of doctors was hit hard: 14 Jewish doctors, either Italian or with acquired citizenship, were expelled from the Medical Register and consequently could no longer practice their profession.
Six Jewish doctors, due to political merits, were not expelled but merely discriminated against, and therefore were able to continue working.
In the category of lawyers too, there were 12 professionals expelled and 6 discriminated against.
As for chartered accountants, engineers and pharmacists, there is no precise news regarding the number of those expelled and those discriminated against. Little news is also available concerning notaries, while it is known that the career Jewish officers expelled from the army numbered five.
Many secondary school teachers were affected by the racial measures.
Jews were also excluded from all centres of socialisation in civil life, such as the National Union of Retired Officers, the Merchants' Club, the Tennis Club, etc. Among the various racial measures, there were some that “deserve” to be mentioned: in the University Library, books written by Jews had to bear the red wording “Lib.Sg.”, meaning “undesirable book”, on the cover, title page, back cover and catalogue card! Another measure prohibited the granting of commercial licenses to Jews; another imposed the deletion of Jewish names from telephone directories; another banned the trade of schoolbooks written by Jews … and finally, things went so far as to change the name of a street: via de’ Giudei became via delle Due Torri!
After a century of civil and religious freedom, the racial laws were a very hard blow for the Jews, before whom rose, terrible and menacing, the spectre of a past almost forgotten by the old and ignored by the young.
The majority of Jews understood that to face the new situation with some hope of survival, it was necessary to rediscover the ancient solidarity, faith and traditional values of times past, which had waned and partly disappeared with achieved well-being and conquered security.
But there were also Jews who sought other means to escape the dangers that were looming in the future. The most valid one seemed to many to be “leaving Judaism”. But how?
There were three paths. To abjure the faith of one's ancestors and be baptised; Aryanisation; or finally, to obtain discrimination.
Abjuration is the renunciation or solemn retraction of one's faith: it is not known how many Jews abjured and were baptised “out of conviction” or “out of expediency”: it is certain that the former were very few. But overall, many had themselves baptised, because Catholic priests baptised everyone who asked.
According to information gathered from the Curia, baptisms with abjuration were:
- in 1937 n. 4
- in 1938 n. 80
- in 1939 n. 52
- in 1940 n. 13
- in 1941 n. 53
When the war ended, many baptised Jews returned to the religion of their fathers, abandoning a “forced Christianity” imposed by tragic circumstances.
Aryanisation consisted of a complex procedure aimed at having the applicant declared as not belonging to the Jewish race, and therefore to be considered Aryan.
To achieve this, one had to prove having an Aryan ancestor, or being an “adulterous child” of a Jewish mother and an Aryan father. It was even more convincing if the mother herself declared her own adultery!
The application to be declared Aryan had to be submitted to a special Commission, called the “Tribunal of Race”, at the Ministry of the Interior.
It is unknown how many cases of Aryanisation there were in Bologna.
Discrimination made use of an exception contained in the racial law, desired by the Grand Council of Fascism, which reserved favourable treatment for Jews and their families who had participated in the war of Libya, the World War, the war of Ethiopia and the Spanish Civil War; for Jews who fell or were mutilated in the “Fascist revolution”; for members enrolled in the PNF between 1919 and 1924; and for families having “exceptional merits” ascertainable by a special Commission. This latter requirement, ambiguous and uncertain, could be considered “reserved” only to those who had, or could procure, “influential friends”…